The Phreakonomist’s Weblog

Finance ex Machina

  • Former Marine turned buy-side equity analyst parsing reality from wikiality

  • Twitter Updates

    • Happy Birthday everyone. You know who you are. 2 days ago
    • Was Larry David ever funny at some point? Can't tell if its bad acting or bad writing by Woody Allen. 4 days ago
    • Has anyone checked whether Pelosi is a V or not? She does seem rather reptilian... 4 days ago
    • picked up a case from Newport Vineyards. 4 days ago
    • loving Jon Stewart's Glenn Beck impression! 5 days ago
    • Primary dealers will do large reverse repos with Fed in exchange 4 lower Tier 1 capital requirements. Here we go again... 5 days ago
    • Can we agree to a moratorium on the use of the term "bourgeois" for a solid decade or so? 6 days ago
    • Remember remember the 5th of November the gunpowder treason & plot. I know of no reason y the gunpowder treason should ever b 4got. 6 days ago
    • I need an 80's band power chord sound effect for my market monitor on days like this! Nice to have TEL out of the index. 1 week ago
  • Categories

Did I Imagine the Anthrax Attacks?

Posted by 史蒂芬 on 17 January 2009

As President Bush bids farewell to the nation, he appears to be using the reductio ad absurdum arguement to prove that his decisions have made America safer though I have my doubts as to whether he put any thought into his logic selection. The arguement implies several assumptions that the sorry excuses for journalists seem unwilling to challenge: 1) Americans do not travel outside of our borders so attacks on our embassies do not count. 2) Domestic terrorism does not count. 3) Natural disasters should be managed by local authorities (the same people who are evacuating their families). 4) The fact that we have an all volunteer military (not counting stop loss) means that the life of an American soldier, sailor, marine, airmen, or even a coastie is worth less than an American civilian unless the Iraq war saved more than four thousand American civilian lives. Even if we assume that there would have been another equally successful attack equivelant to the September 11th attacks, the Iraq war has still resulted in more Americans dead and we have not prevented the threat of the same attack in the future. I certainly feel safer, but of course I am still alive.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>